Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Is a settlement binding if it doesn’t say where the easement goes? Hicken v. Van Wagoner

2026 UT App 164No. 20250685-CADecided Oct 29, 2026Real Property & Land UseReversed & Remanded

Holding

Because the Settlement Agreement did not clearly describe the easement’s width, location, or path and the district court made no factual findings on the parties’ intent, the court could not decide enforceability as a matter of law, so it reversed the enforcement orders, vacated the fee awards, and remanded.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals mostly sided with the Hickens, who appealed, undoing the orders enforcing their settlement and sending the case back.

  • A settlement that leaves out key terms, like an easement’s width and path, may not be enforceable unless it gives a way to fill them in or the parties agreed on them some other way.
  • The district court must make factual findings about what the parties intended before deciding whether the settlement is a binding contract.
  • The attorney fee awards are undone for now, and the Van Wagoners’ request for fees on appeal was denied.

What happened?

The Hickens and the Van Wagoners own neighboring land in Wallsburg, Utah. In 2017 the Hickens sued to move the property line and to get a prescriptive easement, a right to cross someone else’s land gained through long use, mainly for their farm equipment.

Shortly before a January 2023 trial, the lawyers traded drafts by email and signed a written settlement. It set the boundary at the old fence line and said the Van Wagoners would grant an agricultural easement across their property. It also said the Van Wagoners would provide a 16-foot-wide gate and that a new survey would describe the easement. The court canceled the trial.

What went wrong?

A draft survey later showed a 32-foot-wide easement. The Van Wagoners’ lawyer objected, and the Hickens’ lawyer at the time replied that “16′ would be fine.” The Hickens later argued the settlement was only an agreement to agree and asked for a trial.

The district court granted three motions by the Van Wagoners to enforce the settlement. It ordered a 16-foot-wide easement running in a straight line across the Van Wagoners’ land and awarded attorney fees on two of the motions. Both sides appealed.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It reversed. A contract needs a “meeting of the minds,” meaning real agreement, on its essential terms. The settlement did not clearly state the easement’s width, location, or path. A contract missing a term can still be enforced if it gives a method for working the term out later, or if the parties agreed on it outside the written document.

The district court made no factual findings about what the parties intended. It said it was holding the parties to what their lawyers told the court. Without those findings, the appeals court could not decide whether the settlement was enforceable, or whether the Hickens’ former lawyer had authority to agree to the 16-foot width.

The court also refused to consider the Hickens’ statute of frauds argument (a rule requiring certain land deals to be in writing), because they did not raise it in the district court first.

What about attorney fees?

Because the enforcement orders were reversed, the fee awards were vacated, meaning set aside. If the district court later finds the settlement binding, it must decide whether each side acted in good faith or breached, and when. Any fees must be limited to those spent fixing a breach.

The Van Wagoners asked for their fees on appeal, but the court denied that request because they did not win the appeal.

What happens now?

The case goes back to the district court to find the facts and decide whether the parties agreed on the essential terms of the settlement. It may then revisit attorney fees.

What should people take from this?

A settlement that leaves an easement’s size and route to a later survey can open a new dispute. Whether it binds the parties may depend on evidence of what they meant.

Bottom line

Reversed and remanded (Oliver, J., joined by Harris and Luthy, JJ.). The district court granted three motions to enforce a pretrial settlement of a boundary and prescriptive easement dispute without making factual findings. Because fact questions remain on the easement’s essential terms, the court reversed all three enforcement orders and remanded for findings on whether there was a meeting of the minds (¶¶ 22–23, 27).

Issue 1: Enforceability of the Settlement Agreement (mixed, ¶¶ 15, 17–23): reversed

The court could not decide as a matter of law whether the Settlement Agreement is enforceable, so it reversed and remanded for factual findings. The agreement describes a 16-foot gate and says a survey “shall also describe the easement,” but does not state the easement’s width or path (¶ 19). A missing term does not defeat a contract if the parties include a method to ascertain it, Regal RealSource LLC v. Enlaw LLC, 2024 UT App 95, ¶ 25, 554 P.3d 1112, and parol evidence may show whether the parties agreed on missing terms and whether a term is essential (¶¶ 18, 20, citing Regal RealSource LLC v. Enlaw LLC, 2024 UT App 95, ¶ 26, 554 P.3d 1112). The Hickens called it an agreement to agree; the Van Wagoners argued paragraph 2 let them choose the easement’s location on their own (¶ 20). The district court made no findings, relying instead on counsel’s representations, so the appellate court could not decide enforceability or McGinn’s authority to agree to the width. It cited R.O.A. Gen. Inc. v. Salt Lake City Corp., 2022 UT App 141, ¶ 39, 525 P.3d 100: “a court of review, not of first view” (¶ 22).

Issue 5: Attorney fee awards (abuse of discretion, ¶¶ 24–26, 28): reversed

The fee awards were vacated because they depended on the reversed enforcement orders (¶¶ 24, 28). If the settlement is found enforceable, the court must find whether each party’s conduct was good-faith negotiation or performance under paragraph 9 or a breach, and when any breach occurred. Fees must be limited to those incurred in remedying the breach (¶¶ 25–26).

Issue 6: Cross-appeal on fees for the third motion (abuse of discretion, ¶¶ 24–26, 28): remand guidance

The Van Wagoners’ challenge to the denial of fees on the third motion goes back to the district court, which “may revisit the issue” under the same guidance (¶¶ 26, 28).

Issue 7: Fees on appeal (none stated, ¶ 28 n.5): the Van Wagoners’ request for attorney fees on appeal denied

The Van Wagoners did not prevail on appeal, so their request was denied (¶ 28 n.5, citing Gardiner v. Anderson, 2022 UT 42, ¶ 20, 523 P.3d 184).

Not reached

  • Issue 2: The Hickens’ statute of frauds argument that McGinn lacked written authority to agree to the 16-foot width was not preserved (¶ 19 n.3, citing Abu-Ulba v. Ananda Sci., Inc., 2026 UT 24, ¶ 22, 594 P.3d 565). The court added that Utah Code § 25-5-1 would not apply anyway, because the Van Wagoners, not the Hickens, were conveying the interest.
  • Issues 3 and 4: Whether McGinn’s “16′ would be fine” email validly modified the agreement, and whether an evidentiary hearing was required on the third motion, were unnecessary given the reversal (¶ 16 n.2).

Takeaways

  • A settlement that leaves an easement’s description to a later survey may be unenforceable unless it supplies a method to fix the term or a parol agreement covers it (¶¶ 18, 20–21).
  • Enforcing a settlement on counsel’s representations, with no findings on intent, leaves the appellate court nothing to review on disputed essential terms (¶ 22).
  • Under a fee clause that excludes good-faith performance, fees are limited to remedying the breach, and the court must find when the breach occurred (¶ 26).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Hicken v. Van Wagoner
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 164
Case no.
20250685-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
October 29, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Hicken · cross-appeal by Van Wagoner
Disposition
Reversed and Remanded
At stake
Enforcement of a settlement agreement fixing a boundary line at an old fence line and granting the Hickens an agricultural easement across the Van Wagoners' parcel, plus attorney fees.

The panel

Amy J. OliverAuthor
Ryan M. HarrisConcurred
John D. LuthyConcurred
Trial court
Fourth District Court, Heber Department · Judge Jennifer A. Mabey

Parties & counsel

Hicken — Appellant / Cross-appelleeIndividual(s)D. David LambertLeslie W. Slaugh
Van Wagoner — Appellee / Cross-appellantIndividual(s)Edwin C. BarnesNathaniel Broadhurst

Practice Tip

When a settlement leaves an easement's description to a later survey, ask the district court for findings on intent and on any method for fixing the missing terms before enforcement, since the appellate court will not make those findings itself (¶¶ 21–22).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.