Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Does a school have to give parents a copy of a class video? Sevier County School Dist. v. Kummer

2026 UT App 119No. 20250825-CADecided Aug 6, 2026Administrative & GovernmentReversed

Holding

FERPA education records remain subject to GRAMA after the 2016 amendment to Utah Code § 63G-2-107(2), but their disclosure is governed by FERPA, and a school district satisfies that disclosure duty by letting parents inspect and review the record, so it need not provide a redacted copy.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the Sevier County School District, which appealed, and reversed the order requiring it to give the parents a copy of the video.

  • Student education records are still covered by Utah’s public records law, GRAMA, but the federal student-privacy law, FERPA, decides what must be disclosed.
  • Letting the parents watch the video at the school met the district’s duty in this case, so it did not have to give them a redacted copy.
  • The court denied the parents’ request for attorney fees on appeal because the district’s appeal was not frivolous.

What happened?

A middle-school physical education teacher had students do continuous exercise for a forty-five-minute class as punishment for vandalism at the school. Afterward, the Kummers’ daughter complained of injuries. Her parents, Shana and Jared Kummer, asked the Sevier County School District to investigate, and later asked for a copy of video from a camera in the corner of the gym.

The daughter appears in the video, along with about twenty other students. The District gave the parents a four-page written summary of the video and let them watch the unredacted video at the school. It would not give them a copy.

How did the case get to court?

Each parent filed a request under GRAMA, Utah’s law giving people access to government records. The District denied both requests. The State Records Committee, the state board that hears appeals of records denials, ruled that each parent could get a copy with the other students’ faces blurred (redacted) if they paid the cost.

The District, the party that appealed, asked the district court to set that aside. The district court instead ordered the District to provide a redacted copy if the Kummers paid for the redaction.

What did the District argue?

It made two arguments, both based on FERPA, a federal law protecting the privacy of student records. First, it argued that FERPA records are not covered by GRAMA at all. Second, it argued that even if GRAMA applies, FERPA sets the disclosure rules, and FERPA was satisfied when the parents watched the video.

What did the court decide on the first argument?

The court rejected it. In an earlier case, Bryner v. Canyons School District, 2015 UT App 131, 351 P.3d 852, the court had held that FERPA governs how GRAMA requests for student records are handled. A 2016 change to GRAMA used nearly the same words, saying disclosure of FERPA records “shall be governed by” FERPA. The court read that as adopting Bryner, not overruling it. The legislature said elsewhere in the same section that GRAMA “does not apply” to health records, and it chose not to say that about student records.

What about the second argument?

The District won on this one. FERPA requires schools to let parents “inspect and review” their child’s records. Using dictionary meanings and federal Department of Education guidance, the court held that letting the parents watch the video at the school satisfied that duty. Federal guidance says a copy is generally not required unless circumstances effectively prevent a parent from inspecting the record. A school could give a redacted copy without breaking FERPA, but it does not have to.

The court noted that in Bryner the school never offered to let the parent watch the video, so that case did not answer this question.

What happens now?

The order requiring the District to give the Kummers a redacted copy is reversed. The court also denied the Kummers’ request for attorney fees on appeal, because the District’s appeal was “far from frivolous.”

What should people take from this?

Parents can use GRAMA to ask for school records about their child, but FERPA decides what they get. In this case, a chance to watch the video at the school was all the law required.

Bottom line

Reversed (Harris, J., joined by Luthy and Oliver, JJ.). FERPA education records remain subject to GRAMA, but their disclosure is governed by FERPA, which required only that the District let the Kummers “inspect and review” the video. Letting them watch the unredacted video at the school discharged that duty, so the District did not have to produce a redacted copy (¶¶ 29, 31–32). All parties agreed the video is a FERPA education record (¶ 25).

Issue 1: Are FERPA records outside GRAMA after 2016? (correctness, ¶ 11): affirmed (no error)

The 2016 amendment did not remove FERPA education records from GRAMA’s reach; it codified Bryner v. Canyons School District, 2015 UT App 131, 351 P.3d 852 (¶¶ 18, 20, 23). Bryner held that “FERPA’s requirements govern the disclosure under GRAMA” of FERPA records, and the amendment says disclosure “shall be governed by” FERPA, matching that language (¶ 20). The legislature left intact, in the same section, the provision that GRAMA “does not apply” to records containing protected health information, and chose different words for FERPA records; the court presumed the omission purposeful under Belnap v. Howard, 2019 UT 9, ¶ 27, 437 P.3d 355 (¶ 21). Because the text is unambiguous, the court did not consult the legislative history the District offered, citing Zilleruelo v. Commodity Transporters, Inc., 2022 UT 1, ¶ 31, 506 P.3d 509 (¶ 22). In n.2 it added that the comments came from two legislators, were themselves ambiguous, and in any event could not override the text (¶ 22 n.2). FERPA sets the disclosure requirements, while GRAMA supplies the framework for fees, deadlines, and appeals (¶ 23).

Issue 2: FERPA’s “inspect and review” requirement (correctness, ¶ 11): reversed

The District fully satisfied FERPA’s, and therefore GRAMA’s, disclosure requirements by letting the Kummers watch the unredacted video at the school (¶ 29). FERPA, 20 U.S.C. § 1232g(a)(1)(A), does not define “inspect and review,” so the court used dictionary definitions, which describe looking at and examining something closely (¶ 27). Department of Education guidance says FERPA generally does not require release of copies of a video unless circumstances effectively prevent inspection, see 34 C.F.R. § 99.10(d) (¶ 28). The court relied on C.S.A. v. Bellevue School Dist. No. 405, 557 P.3d 268, 280 n.22 (Wash. Ct. App. 2024), for the point that providing a redacted copy would not violate FERPA but is not compelled (¶ 29). Bryner is distinguished: nothing there shows the school offered viewing or argued that viewing satisfied FERPA (¶ 30). The parties agreed the 2016 version of the statute applies (¶ 25 n.3).

Issue 3: Rule 33 attorney fees (none stated, ¶ 32 n.4): the Kummers’ request for attorney fees on appeal denied

The appeal was not frivolous. Rule 33 fees are for “egregious cases,” per Marroquin v. Marroquin, 2019 UT App 38, ¶ 36, 440 P.3d 757; the District’s first argument, though rejected, was not frivolous, and it prevailed on its second (¶ 32 n.4).

Takeaways

  • After 2016, GRAMA still applies to FERPA education records, but FERPA sets the disclosure standard; GRAMA governs fees, deadlines, and appeals (¶ 23).
  • Allowing a parent to inspect and review a FERPA record, such as a multi-student video, at the school satisfies the disclosure duty; a copy is not compelled, though providing a redacted one would not necessarily violate FERPA (¶ 29).
  • Bryner’s redacted-copy outcome does not control where the school offered viewing and argued that viewing satisfied FERPA (¶ 30).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Sevier County School Dist. v. Kummer
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 119
Case no.
20250825-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
August 6, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Sevier County School Dist.
Disposition
Reversed
At stake
Whether the school district had to give parents a redacted copy of a video of their daughter's middle-school physical education class, at the parents' cost, after letting them watch it at the school

The panel

Ryan M. HarrisAuthor
John D. LuthyConcurred
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Trial court
Sixth District Court, Richfield Department · Judge Mandy L. Larsen

Parties & counsel

Sevier County School Dist. — AppellantGovernment agencyDerek E. BrownPeggy E. Stone
Kummer — AppelleeIndividual(s)Amy L. Martz

Practice Tip

When a GRAMA request seeks a FERPA education record, check whether the school has offered the parent a chance to inspect and review it; the court held that offer, once accepted, satisfied the school's disclosure duty and no copy was compelled (¶¶ 29–31).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.