Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Must sentences for crimes in prison run back to back? STATE v. RODRIGUEZ

2026 UT App 174No. 20251224-CADecided Nov 19, 2026Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

Because Rodriguez did not argue below that Utah Code § 76-3-401(3) leaves multiple new sentences free to run concurrently with each other, and the statute is ambiguous on that point with no clearly settled appellate law (the footnote in State v. Neilson, 2017 UT App 7, ¶ 26 n.6, 391 P.3d 398, being dicta of uncertain binding force), the district court did not plainly err in running the new sentences consecutively to each other.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and upheld Rodriguez’s back-to-back sentences.

  • Rodriguez’s argument about how the statute should be read was not raised in the district court, so the appeals court reviewed it only for obvious error.
  • The court called the statute ambiguous on whether multiple new sentences must run back to back with each other, and found no settled case law answering that question.
  • The sentences stand; the court did not decide which reading of the statute is correct.

What happened?

While Rodriguez was in prison for an earlier offense, handmade weapons were found in his possession twice. He was charged with two felonies. In a plea deal, the State reduced each charge to a class A misdemeanor and Rodriguez pled guilty to both.

At sentencing, his lawyer asked for concurrent sentences, meaning sentences served at the same time. The lawyer said the crimes were not violent and that Rodriguez’s parole board hearing had already been pushed back. The lawyer ended by saying, “We understand the presumption in the statute, and we’ll just submit it on that.”

The State argued the statute called for the new sentences to run consecutively, meaning one after another, both to his current sentence and to each other. The court agreed it “really [didn’t] have a choice” and imposed 364 days for each count, all back to back.

What did Rodriguez argue on appeal?

Rodriguez accepted that Utah Code § 76-3-401(3) presumptively requires a new sentence to run after the sentence a prisoner is already serving. But he argued it says nothing about whether two new sentences must run after each other.

Could the court consider that argument?

Only in a limited way. Appeals courts usually consider only arguments that were first made to the trial court, which is called preserving an issue. The court held Rodriguez never made this argument at sentencing. His lawyer asked for concurrent sentences in general and never disagreed with the State’s reading of the statute. The court said the trial court likely had no idea it was being asked to interpret the statute.

The State also argued Rodriguez had invited the error by “just submit[ting]” on the statute. The court disagreed: that was going along with the ruling, not encouraging it.

Did the district court make an obvious error?

No. Because the argument was not preserved, Rodriguez had to show “plain error,” an error that should have been obvious to the trial judge and that caused harm. The court focused only on whether any error was obvious.

It found the statute could reasonably be read either side’s way, so it is ambiguous. Rodriguez pointed to a footnote in an earlier case, State v. Neilson, 2017 UT App 7, ¶ 26 n.6, 391 P.3d 398, that read the statute his way. But that footnote was dicta, a comment not needed to decide that case. The court said it was “something of a close question” whether that comment binds later courts, so it was not obvious that it settled the issue.

What happens now?

Rodriguez’s sentences stand as ordered. The court called the statute question “an interesting one with good arguments on both sides” but did not decide which reading is right.

What should people take from this?

A general request for a lighter sentence may not preserve a specific argument about what a statute means. When the other side offers a reading of a statute, a party who disagrees needs to say so to the trial court, or later review is limited to obvious errors.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Harris, J., joined by Christiansen Forster and Oliver, JJ.). Rodriguez’s reading of Utah Code § 76-3-401(3), that the consecutive-sentence presumption applies only between a new sentence and the one already being served, was not preserved, and the district court did not plainly err in running the two new 364-day sentences consecutively to each other (¶¶ 13, 25–26).

Issue 1: Consecutive sentences under § 76-3-401(3) (plain error, ¶ 7): affirmed (no error)

The interpretation argument was unpreserved, and the district court’s reading was not obvious error.

Preservation (¶¶ 8–13). Counsel said only that the defense “underst[ood] the presumption in the statute” and would “just submit it on that,” and never opposed the State’s reading that the new sentences run consecutively to each other (¶ 11). A general request for concurrent sentences would likely have been understood as invoking the statute’s exception for sentences found inappropriate, not as a competing interpretation (¶ 12). Following Bluffdale City v. Verive, 2026 UT App 101, ¶ 43, 595 P.3d 1128, the court said the district court likely did not know an interpretive question was before it (¶ 13). Even if the court had taken up the theory on its own, that would not end the inquiry, see Abu-Ulba v. Ananda Sci., Inc., 2026 UT 24, ¶ 28, 594 P.3d 565 (¶ 12 n.1).

Invited error (¶ 14 n.2). The State’s invited-error argument failed: “just submit[ting]” was acquiescence, not invitation, under State v. Marquina, 2020 UT 66, ¶ 28, 478 P.3d 37.

Plain error (¶¶ 14–25). The court decided only the obviousness element (¶ 15). Rodriguez relied on the word “later offense” and the surplusage canon; the State relied on “state offenses” and deterrence policy (¶¶ 17–18). Both readings are reasonable, so the statute is ambiguous (¶ 19). The footnote in State v. Neilson, 2017 UT App 7, ¶ 26 n.6, 391 P.3d 398, reading the statute Rodriguez’s way, was dicta, and whether it is binding judicial dicta or nonbinding obiter dicta under Greyhound Lines, Inc. v. Utah Transit Auth., 2020 UT App 144, ¶ 51, 477 P.3d 472, is “something of a close question” (¶¶ 21–25). Because it is not obvious that the footnote is settled appellate law, the claim fails for lack of obvious error (¶ 25).

Takeaways

  • Asking for concurrent sentences does not preserve a specific statutory-interpretation theory, particularly when the statute has an exception the request could be read to invoke (¶ 12).
  • Silence in the face of the opposing party’s stated reading of a statute leaves the trial court unaware of any interpretive dispute (¶¶ 11, 13).
  • Saying a party will “just submit it” on a statutory presumption is acquiescence, not invited error (¶ 14 n.2).
  • Dicta can be settled law for plain error purposes only if it is clearly judicial dicta; the court left open whether the Neilson footnote is binding (¶¶ 21, 25).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
STATE v. RODRIGUEZ
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 174
Case no.
20251224-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
November 19, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
RODRIGUEZ
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Whether two 364-day sentences for weapons offenses committed in prison had to run consecutively to each other, not just to the sentence already being served.

The panel

Ryan M. HarrisAuthor
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterConcurred
Amy J. OliverConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Charles Stormont

Parties & counsel

RODRIGUEZ — AppellantIndividual(s)Nathalie S. Skibine
STATE — AppelleeState of UtahDerek E. BrownGregory W. Marsh

Practice Tip

When the State argues at sentencing that § 76-3-401(3) makes multiple new sentences presumptively consecutive to each other, object and offer the competing reading on the record; a general request for concurrent sentences was not enough to preserve it (¶¶ 11–13).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.