Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a juvenile court choose guardianship instead of ending parents’ rights? In re P.S.

2026 UT App 175No. 20251502-CADecided Nov 19, 2026Juvenile & Child WelfareAffirmed

Holding

A juvenile court’s best-interest ruling declining to terminate parental rights and ordering a permanent guardianship receives the same clear-weight deference as a termination ruling, and the court properly considered the parents’ progress, possible harm from a continuing relationship, and the kinship preference, which requires due weight but is not conclusive.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the parents, upholding the juvenile court’s refusal to end their rights and sending the case back to appoint a permanent guardian.

  • A juvenile court may weigh a parent’s progress in recovery when deciding whether ending parental rights is in a child’s best interest.
  • A juvenile court may consider whether an ongoing relationship with a parent would harm the child.
  • Placement with relatives must get “due weight,” but in this case it did not decide the outcome.

What happened?

P.S. (Child) was born in July 2024. His mother, J.S. (Mother), and his father, H.S. (Father), both had long histories of drug use and domestic violence with each other. In February 2025, after Mother relapsed and was hospitalized, the State filed a petition saying Child had been abused and neglected. Child went to live with Mother’s brother and his wife (Relatives).

The State then asked the juvenile court to terminate, or permanently end, both parents’ rights. By the time of the three-day trial in late 2025, both parents had made real progress. Mother had been in recovery for six months, had a job and lived in a sober living house. Father had stayed in recovery, led a weekly recovery group, kept a job and had stable housing.

What did the juvenile court decide?

The court found legal grounds to end the parents’ rights, but decided that doing so was not in Child’s best interest. Instead, it chose a permanent guardianship, where another adult raises the child while the parents keep their rights. The court reasoned this would let Child keep a relationship with his parents if it was not harmful, while letting the guardian limit contact if a parent relapsed.

Relatives had testified they would only adopt, not serve as guardians. The court preferred them anyway and gave them a chance to reconsider. If they declined, a couple who knew Mother’s grandparents through church (Family Friends) would be appointed. Before that happened, the State and the guardian ad litem (the lawyer appointed to represent the child’s interests) appealed.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It affirmed. The court stressed that the Utah Supreme Court requires a “high degree of deference” to juvenile courts on these decisions, which can be reversed only if against the clear weight of the evidence. It said much of the appeal asked it to reweigh the evidence, which it would not do.

On the specific complaints, the court held:

  • Considering the parents’ progress was proper; Utah law tells courts to weigh it.
  • Asking whether a continuing relationship with a parent would harm Child was proper.
  • The juvenile court gave “due weight” to placing Child with relatives, even though it did not treat that as decisive.
  • Giving Relatives a second chance to become guardians was not coercion.
  • The claim about harm from moving Child away from Relatives was not yet ripe, meaning it had not happened yet and may never happen, and in any event the court did consider it.
  • Several of the guardian ad litem’s arguments were not explained enough in its brief to be considered.

What happens now?

The case goes back to the juvenile court, which had paused the hearing where it would decide who will serve as Child’s permanent guardian.

Did all the judges agree?

Yes. Judge Harris joined fully but wrote separately. The opinion notes that the State and guardian ad litem had asked the Supreme Court to limit appellate review in this area. Judge Harris urged that court to revisit how much deference applies in termination cases, citing concerns about consistency across the state.

What should people take from this?

The deference that usually protects decisions ending parental rights also protects decisions refusing to end them. Here, a juvenile court’s choice of guardianship over adoption stood.

Bottom line

Affirmed and remanded (Tenney, J., joined by Mortensen, J.; Harris, J., concurring). The State and the GAL each appealed a ruling that termination was not strictly necessary to promote Child’s best interest and that a permanent guardianship was. Applying In re D.S., 2025 UT 11, ¶ 4, 568 P.3d 1060, and In re E.R., 2021 UT 36, ¶ 7, 496 P.3d 58, the court held the deference owed to best-interest rulings applies equally when the ruling favors the parents (¶¶ 27-28). The case returns for the stayed hearing on who will be appointed guardian (¶ 69).

Issue 1: Best-interest ruling declining termination and ordering a permanent guardianship (mixed, ¶¶ 30-68): affirmed (no error)

The juvenile court committed no legal error and its best-interest determination was not against the clear weight of the evidence. Statutory-interpretation questions were reviewed for correctness and the best-interest determination for clear weight (¶¶ 22-23).

Legal authority (¶¶ 30-36). The GAL’s claim that the court ignored the 2024 amendments was inadequately briefed (¶ 30) and in any event at odds with In re D.S., 2025 UT 11, ¶ 11 n.4, which described the amended statute as codifying existing caselaw (¶ 31). The quotation of the disavowed “absolutely essential” language (see In re B.T.B., 2020 UT 60, ¶ 59 n.12, 472 P.3d 827) was an isolated reference the court never relied on (¶ 33). Considering the “strong state policy” favoring natural parents was proper, and the court kept it subordinate to the child’s best interest (¶¶ 34-35).

Parents’ progress (¶¶ 38-41, n.2). Utah Code § 80-4-303(1)(b) directs courts to consider parental efforts at the termination phase; doing so does not invert the child-focused analysis.

Child’s point of view (¶¶ 42-45). The court’s remarks about an infant’s likely wishes were “unusually phrased” but showed no reversible error, given the statutes’ child’s-point-of-view directive and the “any other factor” provisions.

Harmfulness (¶¶ 46-49). A juvenile court may consider whether a continuing parental relationship would harm the child, consistent with In re L.L.B., 2023 UT App 66, ¶ 24, 532 P.3d 592, and In re D.S., 2025 UT 11, ¶ 55 (¶¶ 48-49).

Kinship preference (¶¶ 51-56). Section 80-4-104(12)(b)(ii) requires “due weight,” not a conclusive preference; the court weighed Relatives’ status and still gave them first priority as guardians.

Coercion (¶¶ 57-60). Offering Relatives a second chance to serve as guardians was “commendable,” not coercive.

Sections 80-4-303 and -304 (¶¶ 61-62). The GAL’s argument did not identify a specific error and amounted to a request to rebalance.

Harm from removal (¶¶ 63-65). Not yet ripe because Relatives have not chosen; in any event the court did consider the harm.

Feasible options (¶¶ 66-68). The GAL’s three arguments under § 80-4-301(2)(d) were inadequately briefed: no record cites and no developed analysis.

Separate opinion

Judge Harris concurred fully (¶ 70), noting that the State and GAL had sought the deferential standard in In re D.S., 2025 UT 11, 568 P.3d 1060, and In re A.H., 2024 UT 26, 554 P.3d 969 (¶ 71). He urged the supreme court to revisit that standard, citing tension with State v. Torres-Orellana, 2024 UT 46, ¶¶ 64–65, 562 P.3d 706 (¶¶ 74-84).

Takeaways

  • Clear-weight deference applies to best-interest rulings that decline termination, not only those that grant it (¶ 28).
  • A parent’s progress is a statutory factor in the best-interest analysis under § 80-4-303(1)(b) (¶¶ 39-41).
  • A court may consider whether a continuing parental relationship would harm the child (¶ 49).
  • Arguments made in a sentence, without record cites or developed authority, will be rejected as inadequately briefed (¶ 68).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
In re P.S.
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 175
Case no.
20251502-CA
Filed
2025
Decided
November 19, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
The State's petition to terminate both parents' rights to their child, which the juvenile court denied in favor of a permanent guardianship.

The panel

Ryan D. TenneyAuthor
Ryan M. HarrisConcurring opinion
David N. MortensenConcurred
Trial court
Fifth Juvenile Court, St. George Department · Judge Michael F. Leavitt

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantGovernment agencyDerek E. BrownDeborah A. WoodJohn M. Peterson
Appellee — AppelleeIndividual(s)Colleen K. CoeberghSheleigh A. Harding
Guardian ad litemOtherMartha PierceAlisha GilesHeath Haacke

Practice Tip

When appealing a best-interest ruling, identify a specific legal error with record cites and developed authority; arguments that amount to reweighing, or that appear in a sentence or two, will fail (¶¶ 28, 68).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.