Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a company that leased equipment sue the seller for fraud? Multiactivos Leasing v. Eco Green Equipment

2026 UT App 176No. 20241111-CADecided Nov 19, 2026Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed/Reversed in part

Holding

A seller cannot be liable for fraud or negligent misrepresentation to a buyer’s lessee when no evidence shows the seller knew, before signing the sales contract, that the buyer intended to lease the equipment to another entity, and without any remaining damages punitive damages are unavailable under Utah Code § 78B-8-201(1)(a).

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with Eco Green on every issue, throwing out the fraud verdicts and leaving the punitive damages awards vacated.

  • A fraud or negligent misrepresentation claim failed because there was no evidence the seller knew, when it made its statements, that the buyer planned to lease the equipment to another company.
  • A company that was never named in the sales contract was not a third-party beneficiary of it under Utah law.
  • Because no other damages remained, the punitive damages awards could not stand.

What happened?

Eco Green Equipment, LLC, a Utah company, sold tire recycling equipment to Multiactivos Leasing, a company based in Guadalajara, Mexico. The price in the Purchase Agreement was $1,696,656, later reduced by $234,328. The agreement said it was governed by the CISG, a United Nations treaty on international sales of goods.

Multiactivos leased the equipment to a related company, Recicladora. The equipment arrived late, and Recicladora said it could process only 20% of what was promised. Both companies sued Eco Green.

What did the jury decide?

The jury found Eco Green did not breach the contract with Multiactivos. It found Eco Green liable to Recicladora for fraud and negligent misrepresentation (a careless false statement made expecting the other side to rely on it) and awarded $1 in nominal damages, a token amount, on each claim. It also awarded punitive damages, meant to punish, of $300,000 to Multiactivos and $200,000 to Recicladora.

The trial judge then threw out the punitive damages, reasoning they could not rest on nominal damages alone. The final judgment against Eco Green was $2.

Why did the damages instruction stand?

The jury was told Multiactivos had to prove the equipment had no market value to recover. Multiactivos and Recicladora said this misstated Utah law.

The Court of Appeals said the instruction came from an earlier ruling limiting the damages they could seek, because their pretrial disclosure of how they calculated damages listed only the purchase price. Their opening brief never challenged that ruling, so the argument was waived, meaning given up.

Could Recicladora sue on the sales contract?

No. The CISG covers only the rights of the buyer and the seller, so the court looked to Utah law. Utah lets an outsider enforce a contract only if the contract itself clearly shows the parties meant to give that outsider a direct benefit. The contract never named Recicladora, so that claim was properly dismissed before trial.

Why were the fraud verdicts thrown out?

Eco Green appealed too. Both claims required proof that Eco Green made its statements to get Recicladora to act, or expecting it to. The court found no evidence that Eco Green knew, before signing the Purchase Agreement, that Multiactivos planned to lease the equipment to anyone. A seller cannot aim statements at a lessee it does not know about. The court reversed and erased the $1 awards.

What about the punitive damages?

With the fraud verdicts gone, no damages of any kind remained. Under Utah law, punitive damages generally require an award of compensatory or general damages. So the court kept the punitive damages off for that different reason, without deciding the trial court’s nominal-damages question.

What should people take from this?

A buyer’s plan to lease goods to someone else may matter for later fraud claims only if the seller knew about that plan when it made its statements. And a company that is never named in a contract will have a hard time claiming rights under it in Utah.

Bottom line

Reversed in part, affirmed in all other respects (Luthy, J., joined by Orme and Christiansen Forster, JJ.) (¶ 47). Multiactivos bought tire recycling equipment from Eco Green under a CISG-governed Purchase Agreement and leased it to Recicladora (¶¶ 6–8). The jury rejected Multiactivos’s contract claim but found Eco Green liable to Recicladora for fraud and negligent misrepresentation, with $1 nominal damages each and punitive awards of $300,000 and $200,000; the district court vacated the punitive awards (¶¶ 23–24). The main holding: no evidence showed Eco Green knew of any lessee when it made the alleged misrepresentations, so Recicladora’s claims failed as a matter of law (¶ 44).

Issue 1: Damages instruction (mixed, ¶ 26): not reached

Appellants’ challenge to Instruction 28I was waived because they never challenged the rule 26 sanction on which it rested. The district court limited damages to the disclosed computation (purchase price minus a “paper-mache” value) and tied the instruction to that ruling, which Multiactivos acknowledged on the record (¶¶ 31–32). The instruction was not a statement of general Utah law, and the opening brief made no rule 26 argument, so the challenge was waived under Allen v. Friel, 2008 UT 56, ¶ 8, 194 P.3d 903 (¶¶ 33–34). A reply-brief claim that the ruling was a purely legal burden ruling contradicted the record (n.3). The court did not decide Eco Green’s preservation argument (n.2).

Issue 2: Third-party beneficiary (correctness, ¶ 27): affirmed (no error)

Recicladora’s third-party beneficiary claim was properly dismissed on summary judgment. CISG article 4 covers only the rights of seller and buyer, so the court applied Utah law, following Cedar Petrochemicals, Inc. v. Dongbu Hannong Chem. Co., No. 06 Civ. 3972, 2007 WL 2059239, at *3 (S.D.N.Y. July 19, 2007) (¶ 37). Utah requires that the contract itself clearly show intent to confer a distinct benefit, Val Peterson Inc. v. Tennant Metals Pty. Ltd., 2023 UT App 115, ¶ 43, 537 P.3d 660 (¶ 38). Neither the Purchase Agreement nor the incorporated Proposal names Recicladora, and the “INDUSTRIAS ECOLAND” cover page did not create an ambiguity that could meet that bar (¶¶ 39–40).

Issue 3: Fraud and negligent misrepresentation (correctness, ¶ 29): reversed

The denial of Eco Green’s motion for judgment as a matter of law is reversed and the nominal damages vacated. Fraud requires a representation made to induce the other party to act, Robinson v. Tripco Inv., Inc., 2000 UT App 200, ¶ 12, 21 P.3d 219, and negligent misrepresentation requires one made expecting the other party to rely, Moore v. Smith, 2007 UT App 101, ¶ 36 n.12, 158 P.3d 562 (¶ 43). The analysis was limited to precontractual statements (n.4), and none of the emails, testimony or shipping evidence Recicladora cited showed Eco Green knew of a lessee before signing (¶ 44 & n.5). The court did not reach the economic loss rule argument (¶ 41).

Issue 4: Punitive damages (correctness, ¶ 28): affirmed on other grounds

The vacatur of the punitive awards stands, though not on the district court’s nominal-damages reasoning, which the court did not address. With the verdicts vacated, no damages remained, and Utah Code § 78B-8-201(1)(a) allows punitive damages “only if compensatory or general damages are awarded” (¶ 45, citing Evans v. B&E Pace Inv. LLC, 2018 UT App 37, ¶ 12 n.3, 424 P.3d 963).

Takeaways

  • An instruction that applies a discovery sanction must be attacked through the sanction itself, in the opening brief (¶¶ 33–34).
  • The CISG does not govern third-party beneficiary rights; Utah’s clear-intent standard applies (¶¶ 37–38).
  • For fraud or negligent misrepresentation by an unnamed lessee, the record must show the speaker knew of the lessee when the statements were made (¶ 44).
  • Whether punitive damages may rest on nominal damages alone was left undecided (¶ 45).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Multiactivos Leasing v. Eco Green Equipment
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 176
Case no.
20241111-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
November 19, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Multiactivos Leasing · cross-appeal by Eco Green Equipment
Disposition
Affirmed in part and Reversed in part
At stake
Jury punitive damages awards of $300,000 and $200,000 that the district court vacated, $1 nominal damages awards on two fraud-related claims, and a breach-of-contract claim for the equipment's purchase price.

The panel

John D. LuthyAuthor
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterConcurred
Gregory K. OrmeConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Todd M. Shaughnessy

Parties & counsel

Multiactivos Leasing — Appellant / Cross-appelleeBusinessAndrew G. DeissCorey D. Riley
Eco Green Equipment — Appellee / Cross-appellantBusinessErik A. OlsonDominic W. Shaw

Practice Tip

When a jury instruction rests on a rule 26 disclosure sanction, challenge the sanction itself in the opening brief; arguing only that the instruction misstates the law will be treated as waived (¶¶ 33–34).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.