Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a parent’s drug charges alone prove child neglect? In re A.L.M.

2026 UT App 177No. 20260001-CADecided Nov 19, 2026Juvenile & Child WelfareReversed

Holding

A parent’s continued drug use, unaccompanied by findings that it led to some lack of care to the child, cannot support a neglect determination under Utah Code § 80-1-102(59)(a), and an unchallenged dependency adjudication does not render error in the neglect determination harmless.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the mother, D.L., and reversed the juvenile court’s finding that her child was neglected as to her.

  • A parent’s drug use, without facts showing it led to a lack of care for the child, did not support a neglect finding here.
  • A parent with only residual rights who takes over a child’s care has a duty to care for the child properly.
  • An unchallenged dependency finding did not stop the mother from appealing the neglect finding.

What happened?

The child, A.L.M. (called Child in the opinion), was first removed from his mother’s care in 2019. In 2021 the juvenile court placed permanent custody and guardianship of Child with his aunt. The mother, D.L., kept only “residual parental rights,” the rights a parent keeps after someone else is given custody and guardianship. That same year the court found the mother unfit because of her habitual use of illegal substances.

From 2022 on, Child lived “on and off” with the aunt and various family members. In October 2025 the State asked the juvenile court to step in, and the Division of Child and Family Services took temporary custody.

How were the facts decided?

The mother answered the State’s petition under rule 34(e) of the Utah Rules of Juvenile Procedure, which treats any allegation not specifically denied as true. The facts included her drug-related charges and convictions, Child being moved from home to home and school to school, and a home visit on October 6, 2025, about a day after Child began living with her, where his bedroom was “a few blankets next to a furnace.”

What did each side argue?

The State asked for a neglect finding. The mother asked instead for a dependency finding, a no-fault finding that a child lacks proper care. She argued it was not clear who was responsible for the neglect Child suffered.

The juvenile court found both. It said the mother’s drug history made “the strongest case for neglect,” and that the other facts were “more indicative of dependency” as to her.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It reversed the neglect finding. First, it refused the State’s request to affirm on the ground that the unchallenged dependency finding made any error harmless. A neglect finding can be a legal ground for ending parental rights later, and a dependency finding cannot, so the mother was entitled to challenge it.

Second, the court agreed with the State that a parent with only residual rights who takes over a child’s care has a duty to provide proper care.

But the court held that the drug-related facts did not support neglect. Neglect requires that the parent’s action or inaction caused a lack of care. Nothing in the findings linked the mother’s drug use to the neglect Child suffered, and the findings showed Child was in her care only in October 2025.

The court also found that the State’s other points overstated the findings. For example, the finding said the mother “and/or” the paternal grandmother sprayed WD-40 on Child’s head, so it did not establish that the mother did it.

What happens now?

The neglect finding and the related finding of chronic neglect are reversed. The dependency finding was not challenged on appeal and remains in force.

What should people take from this?

In this case, a parent’s drug history was not enough to prove neglect without facts connecting it to how the child was actually cared for. Findings that do not say which adult did what may support only a no-fault dependency finding.

Bottom line

Reversed (Christiansen Forster, J., joined by Orme and Luthy, JJ.). On facts deemed true under Utah R. Juv. P. 34(e), the juvenile court adjudicated Child dependent and neglected as to Mother, relying for neglect on her prior child welfare adjudications and drug-related charges (¶¶ 5–7). Those facts did not establish that Mother’s action or inaction caused Child’s lack of care, so the neglect determination is reversed (¶¶ 15, 21–22). The chronic neglect determination falls with it, and the unchallenged dependency determination remains (¶ 22 n.2).

Issue 1: Neglect determination (correctness, ¶ 8): reversed

The adjudicated facts did not support a neglect determination as to Mother. The court reviewed the determination “nondeferentially” as a law-like mixed question, quoting In re A.B., 2022 UT 39, ¶ 28, 523 P.3d 168 (¶ 8).

Harmless error rejected (¶¶ 9–10). The State relied on In re K.K., 2023 UT App 13, 525 P.3d 519, to argue that an unchallenged dependency adjudication meant no prejudice. The court distinguished it because only neglect, not dependency, is a statutory basis for termination under Utah Code § 80-4-301(1), and followed In re A.K.-A., 2026 UT App 167, ¶¶ 22–25, which held that due process lets a parent challenge an at-fault finding on appeal.

Residual parental rights (¶ 12, n.1). A parent with residual rights who voluntarily assumes care and physical custody has a duty to provide proper care, and failing that duty could support neglect. The court relied on Atkinson v. Stateline Hotel Casino & Resort, 2001 UT App 63, ¶ 17, 21 P.3d 667, and persuasive out-of-state authority. It resolved the point because Mother’s arguments still relied on her non-custodial status, though she seemed to have abandoned the argument (n.1).

Drug use and nexus (¶¶ 13–15). Neglect requires that the parent’s “action or inaction” cause the lack of care (Utah Code § 80-1-102(59)(a)). Drug use alone, without facts showing it led to some lack of care, cannot support neglect (¶ 15, citing In re Am. V., 833 A.2d 493, 499 (D.C. 2003); cf. Utah Code § 80-3-110(3), (5)). Mother’s last conviction was in May 2025, and the findings placed Child in her care only in October 2025 (¶ 14).

The State’s other facts (¶¶ 16–20). The findings did not show Mother’s role in Child’s moves, which may have ended with his first stay with her since 2022 (¶ 17). The WD-40 finding said Mother “and/or” the paternal grandmother (¶ 18). The blanket bedroom was seen about a day after Child arrived, and a bed was in storage (¶ 18). The doctor finding showed no current neglect (¶ 19). The findings did not say why the attendance specialist was unsuccessful or show that the refused visits came while Child was with Mother (¶ 20).

Disposition

The neglect and chronic neglect determinations are reversed. The dependency determination remains in force (¶ 22 & n.2).

Takeaways

  • A neglect adjudication premised on drug use needs findings linking that use to a lack of care for the child (¶ 15).
  • An unchallenged dependency adjudication does not make error in a neglect adjudication harmless, given neglect’s termination consequences (¶ 10).
  • A residual-rights parent who assumes physical care owes a duty of proper care (¶ 12).
  • Findings that attribute conduct to several adults collectively, or “and/or,” may not establish a particular parent’s fault (¶¶ 17–18, 21).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
In re A.L.M.
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 177
Case no.
20260001-CA
Filed
2026
Decided
November 19, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Disposition
Reversed
At stake
A juvenile court adjudication that Child was neglected, and chronically neglected, as to Mother, a finding that can serve as a statutory basis for terminating parental rights.

The panel

Michele M. Christiansen ForsterAuthor
John D. LuthyConcurred
Gregory K. OrmeConcurred
Trial court
Third Juvenile Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Susan H. Eisenman

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantIndividual(s)Emily AdamsAllison Herr
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyDerek E. BrownDeborah A. WoodJohn M. Peterson
Guardian ad litemOtherMartha PierceAlisha GilesHeath Haacke

Practice Tip

When drug use is the basis for a neglect allegation, examine whether the adjudicated facts link the use to the child's care during the period the child was with the parent; without that nexus, neglect cannot be sustained (¶¶ 14–15).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.