Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a prison fine stop the State from prosecuting an inmate? State of Utah v. Mendoza

938 P.2d 303No. 950337-CADecided May 15, 1997Criminal AppealsAffirmed

Holding

A $200 prison disciplinary fine is not so overwhelmingly disproportionate to the prison’s remedial goals that it constitutes punishment under United States v. Halper, 490 U.S. 435 (1989), so it does not bar a later prosecution for the same conduct, and the inmate’s failure to make a threshold showing of disproportionality means the State need not account for its costs.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and allowed the assault charge against Mendoza to go forward.

  • A $200 prison disciplinary fine was not “punishment” that barred a later criminal charge for the same conduct.
  • A fine is not punishment just because it partly aims to encourage good behavior; courts compare the fine with the government’s costs.
  • An inmate’s inability to pay does not decide whether a fine is punishment.

What happened?

Mendoza, a prison inmate, allegedly threw a mixture of bodily excretions at a prison guard on August 7, 1994. A prison disciplinary board decided he committed the assault and ordered him to pay a $200 fine and serve thirty days in isolation.

On August 15, 1994, the State charged him in district court with assault on a correctional officer, a class A misdemeanor, for the same incident.

What did Mendoza argue?

Mendoza asked the trial court to dismiss the charge. He relied on double jeopardy, the constitutional rule against punishing someone twice for the same offense. He said the prison’s fine was already punishment. In the alternative, he asked that the State be required to give a more detailed accounting of its costs.

The only evidence at the hearing was a statement from a prison official saying fines help repay the prison for the cost of the hearing and investigation, and also encourage proper inmate behavior. The trial court denied the motion, and Mendoza appealed before any trial. He did not argue on appeal that the isolation was punishment.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It affirmed. The court first explained that whether a fine counts as punishment is a legal question it decides for itself, while the facts underneath it get deference.

Both sides took an all-or-nothing view. Mendoza said any punitive part made the fine punishment. The State said any remedial part (meaning it repays the government) kept it from being punishment. The court rejected both. Relying on United States v. Halper, 490 U.S. 435, 109 S.Ct. 1892, 104 L.Ed.2d 487 (1989) and United States v. Ursery, — U.S. —, 116 S.Ct. 2135, 135 L.Ed.2d 549 (1996), it said courts must weigh the government’s harm against the size of the penalty. A fine becomes punishment only when the gap is “overwhelming.”

So the trial court’s finding that fines partly encourage good behavior did not settle the question.

Did the State have to account for its costs?

No. The court said a defendant must first make a threshold showing that the fine looks like punishment. The court could not see how $200 was overwhelmingly out of proportion to the prison’s costs. Common sense says even a short hearing costs the prison more than a trivial amount, if only in salaries.

Mendoza’s argument centered on his inability to pay based on what he could earn. The court said that does not matter, because the question is the purpose the fine actually serves, not how it feels to the person fined.

What happens now?

The order denying Mendoza’s motion to dismiss stands, so the assault charge goes forward in the district court.

What should people take from this?

A small prison disciplinary fine that plausibly covers the prison’s costs will not, by itself, block a later criminal case over the same conduct. The court also noted that cases about taxes, forfeitures and license suspensions use different tests and do not control this question.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Greenwood, J., joined by Wilkins, Associate P.J., and Jackson, J.). On interlocutory appeal, the court held that a $200 prison disciplinary fine was not “punishment” for double jeopardy purposes, so it did not bar prosecuting Mendoza for assault on a correctional officer under Utah Code Ann. § 76-5-102.6 for the same incident. The opinion has no numbered paragraphs.

Issue 1: Was the $200 fine double jeopardy punishment? (mixed): affirmed (no error)

The fine was not so disproportionate to the prison’s remedial goals that it constituted punishment, and the State need not provide a more detailed accounting.

Standard of review. The parties disputed it. Despite language in United States v. Halper, 490 U.S. 435, 450, 109 S.Ct. 1892, 1902-03, 104 L.Ed.2d 487 (1989) leaving the matter to the trial court, the court held that the ultimate determination of whether a fine is overwhelmingly disproportionate is a question of law reviewed for correctness, following United States v. McClinton, 98 F.3d 1199, 1201-02 (9th Cir.1996) and see generally State v. Pena, 869 P.2d 932, 936-39 (Utah 1994). Underlying findings, such as the State’s actual expenses, are reviewed for clear error (the opinion’s closing sentence says “plain error”).

Merits. The parties agreed the Halper analysis applies. The court rejected both all-or-nothing readings of Halper. Under United States v. Ursery, — U.S. —, 116 S.Ct. 2135, 135 L.Ed.2d 549 (1996), Halper requires a “case-by-case balancing test” comparing the government’s harm with the penalty, and punishment requires an “overwhelming” or “tremendous disparity.” The trial court’s finding that fines partly encourage proper inmate behavior was therefore not dispositive.

A threshold indication of punishment must exist before the State must account for its expenses. The court could not see how $200 was overwhelmingly disproportionate to the prison’s costs; even a short hearing costs more than a de minimis amount in salaries. Mendoza’s focus on his inability to pay was irrelevant, because Halper looks to the purpose the sanction serves, not the defendant’s perspective.

Side points. Mendoza did not claim the isolation was punishment (n.1). His reliance on Department of Revenue v. Kurth Ranch, 511 U.S. 767 (1994), Austin v. United States, 509 U.S. 602 (1993), State v. A House, 886 P.2d 534 (Utah 1994) and State v. Arbon, 909 P.2d 1270 (Utah.Ct.App.) was misplaced, since those cases address “punishment” in different contexts that Ursery warned against mixing (n.2).

Takeaways

  • Whether a civil or administrative fine is double jeopardy punishment is a question of law reviewed for correctness; the facts underneath it are reviewed deferentially.
  • A fine with some deterrent purpose is not automatically punishment; the test compares the penalty with the government’s harm and requires an overwhelming disparity.
  • A defendant must make a threshold showing of disproportionality before the State must account for its costs.
  • The defendant’s ability to pay is irrelevant to whether a sanction is punishment.
Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State of Utah v. Mendoza
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
938 P.2d 303
Case no.
950337-CA
Filed
1995
Decided
May 15, 1997
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Mendoza
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Whether a $200 prison disciplinary fine barred the State from prosecuting an inmate for assault on a correctional officer based on the same incident.

The panel

Pamela T. GreenwoodAuthor
Norman H. JacksonConcurred
Michael J. WilkinsConcurred
Trial court
Third District Court, Sandy Department · Judge Roger A. Livingston, J.

Parties & counsel

Mendoza — AppellantIndividual(s)Joan C. WattJanet Miller
State of Utah — AppelleeState of UtahJan GrahamBrent A. Burnett

Practice Tip

A double jeopardy challenge to an administrative fine should be built on the gap between the fine and the government's actual costs, not on the defendant's ability to pay, which the court held irrelevant; the opinion has no numbered paragraphs to cite.

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.