Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a juvenile court skip a parent’s reunification review hearing? A.E. v. Hon. Arthur G. Christean, Judge, Third District Juvenile Court

938 P.2d 811No. 9700067-CADecided May 1, 1997Juvenile & Child WelfarePetition Granted

Holding

A dispositional review hearing under Utah Code section 78-3a-312 (1996) is mandatory, must be held separately from and may not be combined with a termination of parental rights hearing, and was not waived by a parent who clearly sought to regain custody.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the mother, A.E., and ordered the juvenile court to hold a separate dispositional review hearing.

  • Under the statute in this case, a dispositional review hearing must be held within twelve months after a child is removed.
  • That hearing may not be combined with a trial on whether to terminate parental rights.
  • The mother did not waive the hearing by not asking for it within twelve months, given that she clearly sought to regain custody.

What happened?

A.E. is the mother of N.E. When N.E. was eight months old, a hospital placed N.E. in the protective custody of the Division of Child and Family Services (DCFS) after an exam showed four recent injuries that were not accidental. With A.E.’s consent, the juvenile court placed N.E. with the maternal grandparents.

The juvenile court later found N.E. was an abused child, but also found the State had not proven by clear and convincing evidence (a higher bar than “more likely than not”) that A.E. caused the injuries. It ordered reunification services and required A.E. to complete a service plan. A.E. was later found not guilty of criminal child abuse charges after a jury trial.

How did the dispute arise?

The grandparents, and later the State, filed petitions to terminate A.E.’s parental rights. The State and then A.E. asked for a dispositional review hearing, which is a hearing to decide whether a removed child should go home. The juvenile court, citing judicial economy, combined that hearing with the termination trial. After more delays, A.E. asked the Court of Appeals for extraordinary relief, meaning an order directing the juvenile court to act.

What did each side argue?

A.E. argued the statute required a separate review hearing. Judge Christean, through counsel, argued the juvenile court could combine the hearings to save time and that a separate hearing would be redundant once a termination petition was filed. The State argued A.E. waived the hearing by not asking for it within twelve months, and that the statute did not apply because N.E. was placed with relatives.

What did the court decide?

It granted A.E.’s petition. The statute says a review hearing “shall be held” within twelve months after removal, and “shall” ordinarily means a command. The court reasoned the deadline exists to protect parents by giving them a timely chance to be reunited with their child.

The court also held the review hearing cannot be combined with a termination trial. The law sets out steps in order, and combining them would skip those steps. The two hearings ask different questions and use different burdens of proof, and combining them would place an unfair burden on the parent.

The court rejected the waiver argument because the statute does not say who must request the hearing and A.E. clearly sought to regain custody. It also held the statute covers removal of any kind, including placement with relatives.

What happens now?

The case goes back to the juvenile court, which must hold the dispositional review hearing as the opinion describes.

Did all the judges agree?

Yes. Judge Orme wrote separately to explain that courts can bend rules they made themselves when a child’s interests call for it, but not a mandatory law passed by the Legislature. Any exceptions would be for the Legislature to make.

Bottom line

Petition for extraordinary relief granted and remanded (Greenwood, J., joined by Bench, J.; Orme, J., concurring). The juvenile court consolidated the twelve-month dispositional review hearing with the trial on the grandparents’ and the State’s petitions to terminate A.E.’s parental rights, for judicial economy. The court held the hearing is mandatory under Utah Code section 78-3a-312 and cannot be combined with a termination hearing. The opinion has no numbered paragraphs.

Issue 1: Mandatory, separate dispositional review hearing (correctness): A.E.’s petition for extraordinary relief granted

The juvenile court must hold a dispositional review hearing under section 78-3a-312, and it may not be combined with a termination of parental rights hearing.

Mandatory. The statute’s repeated “shall” is presumed mandatory under plain-language construction, citing Brinkerhoff v. Forsyth, 779 P.2d 685, 686 (Utah 1989) and Board of Educ. v. Salt Lake County, 659 P.2d 1030, 1035 (Utah 1983). Applying the logic of Kennecott Copper Corp. v. Salt Lake County, 575 P.2d 705, 707 (Utah 1978), a time requirement is mandatory when it exists for the benefit of the affected person. Here it protects the parent’s opportunity for a timely hearing on reunification. The 1995 amendment shortening the period from eighteen to twelve months confirms the Legislature wanted the hearing timely. Judicial efficiency cannot alone justify eroding a parent’s interest in reunification, citing State in re J.L.W., 900 P.2d 543, 549 (Utah Ct. App. 1995) and In re Adoption of B.O., 927 P.2d 202, 207 (Utah Ct. App. 1996).

Not combinable. Harmonizing the Act’s sequential steps (sections 78-3a-306, 308, 310, 312, 313), see State v. Souza, 846 P.2d 1313, 1317 (Utah Ct. App. 1993), consolidation would bypass the legislative sequence. Here the process was reversed: termination was pursued before the court decided whether A.E. had complied with the service plan. Combining the hearings also (1) unfairly burdens the parent, (2) merges hearings with different factual and legal issues, and (3) mixes different burdens: preponderance under section 78-3a-312(2)(a) when reunification services were ordered, versus clear and convincing evidence under section 78-3a-406(3).

Waiver. The State’s waiver argument failed: the statute does not say who must request the hearing, and A.E. clearly sought to regain custody (see generally Soter’s Inc. v. Deseret Fed. Sav. & Loan, 857 P.2d 935, 940 (Utah 1993)). The court suggested DCFS and the juvenile courts adopt a standardized scheduling procedure.

Kinship placement. The State’s argument that section 78-3a-312 does not apply because N.E. was placed with relatives failed; the section speaks of removal of any kind (n.7).

Disposition

Remanded for the juvenile court to hold the dispositional review hearing consistent with the opinion.

Separate opinion

Judge Orme concurred, sympathetic to the juvenile court’s caseload. Courts may relax judicially created rules and doctrines in child-welfare cases, but section 78-3a-312 is a mandatory legislative enactment; exceptions are for the Legislature.

Takeaways

  • The twelve-month dispositional review hearing under section 78-3a-312 is mandatory and protects the parent (opinion’s analysis of “shall” and Kennecott).
  • A juvenile court may not consolidate that hearing with a termination trial (Conclusion).
  • A parent who actively seeks custody does not waive the hearing by failing to request it within twelve months.
  • The statute applies to removal of any kind, including kinship placement (n.7).
Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
A.E. v. Hon. Arthur G. Christean, Judge, Third District Juvenile Court
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
938 P.2d 811
Case no.
9700067-CA
Decided
May 1, 1997
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Hon. Arthur G. Christean, Judge, Third District Juvenile Court
Disposition
Petition Granted
At stake
A mother's request for an order requiring the juvenile court to hold a twelve-month dispositional review hearing on reunification with her child, separate from and before the trial on petitions to terminate her parental rights.

The panel

Pamela T. GreenwoodAuthor
Gregory K. OrmeConcurring opinion
Russell W. BenchConcurred
Trial court
Third Juvenile Court · Judge Hon. Arthur G. Christean

Parties & counsel

Hon. Arthur G. Christean, Judge, Third District Juvenile Court — AppellantIndividual(s)John E. Laherty
A.E. — AppelleeGovernment agencyBrent M. JohnsonJan GrahamJeffrey Buckner
Guardian ad litemOtherKristin Fadel

Practice Tip

When a termination petition is filed before the twelve-month dispositional review hearing, a parent's counsel can rely on this opinion to insist on a separate review hearing under section 78-3a-312; the statute covers removal of any kind, including kinship placement (n.7).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.