Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

What if a judge ignores my request for a new public defender? State of Utah v. Vessey

967 P.2d 960No. 951820-CADecided Oct 22, 1998Criminal AppealsReversed & Remanded

Holding

A trial court’s failure to investigate a defendant’s timely pretrial request for substitution of appointed counsel is per se error, but reversal is withheld until an evidentiary hearing on remand establishes a conflict of a magnitude requiring substitution.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals partly sided with the defendant, sending his case back for a hearing on his request for a new lawyer while rejecting his other claims.

  • When a defendant makes a timely pretrial request for a new appointed lawyer, the trial court has to look into the reasons, not deny it without any questions.
  • Here, the fix was a hearing, not an automatic new trial: a new trial follows only if the complaints justified a new lawyer.
  • The court did not consider the victim’s later recanting statements, because they were not evidence at trial.

What happened?

Vessey was charged in February 1995 with rape of a child and was given a court-appointed lawyer. One day after he pleaded not guilty, he filed his own written request asking the court to replace his lawyers. He said they had a “conflict of interest” and that counsel “refuses evidence I have brought forth” for his defense.

The trial court denied the request the same day it was filed, without asking any questions. The case went to a jury trial, and he was convicted.

What did he argue on appeal?

Representing himself, Vessey argued that the court should have looked into his request for a new lawyer, that his trial lawyers were ineffective, that the prosecution hid helpful evidence and witnesses broke the rule keeping them out of the courtroom, that a biased juror should have been removed, that he should have had a new trial, and that the evidence was too weak to convict him.

Was it wrong to deny his request without asking him anything?

Yes. The State itself agreed the trial court erred by not making any real inquiry. The harder question was what to do about it. The State argued the error did no harm unless he showed his lawyers actually performed badly at trial.

The court took a middle path. It held that failing to look into a timely pretrial request is always error. But the conviction is undone only if the complaints turn out to be serious enough that a new lawyer was needed. The court explained that only a trial court hearing held at the time can properly test those complaints, and that without this rule trial courts would have no reason to hold one.

What happens now?

The trial court must hold a hearing, where evidence is taken, on whether his complaints justified a new lawyer. If they did, he gets a new trial. If not, the conviction is entered again.

What about his other claims?

The court did not decide whether his lawyers were ineffective, because the trial record did not show the facts needed to judge that. The hidden-evidence and witness-rule claims, and the juror claim, were not raised at trial, so the court would not consider them. The new-trial request had already been decided in an earlier appeal, which found both motions filed too late.

The challenge to the evidence failed. He relied on the victim’s later statements taking back her testimony, but those were never evidence at trial. The court granted the State’s request to strike them from the appeal record and noted he had not shown the trial evidence was too weak.

What should people take from this?

A timely pretrial complaint about appointed counsel should get a real look from the trial court. If it does not, the remedy may be a hearing first, with a new trial only if the complaints hold up.

Bottom line

Reversed in part and remanded (Billings, J., joined by Greenwood and Orme, JJ.). Facing a question it called one of first impression in Utah, the court adopted a “middle ground”: a trial court’s failure to investigate a timely substitution request is per se error, but reversal waits until “an actual conflict is established” between defendant and counsel “of a magnitude requiring substitution of counsel.” The remaining claims failed or were not reached.

Issue 1: Failure to inquire into substitution request (abuse of discretion): reversed and remanded

Summarily denying a timely pretrial pro se substitution request, with no inquiry, was error requiring a remand for an evidentiary hearing. Under State v. Pursifell, 746 P.2d 270, 278 (Utah Ct.App.1987), the court must make “reasonable, non-suggestive efforts” to learn the nature of the complaints, and “perfunctory questioning is not sufficient.” The State conceded the abuse of discretion but argued harmlessness absent actual ineffectiveness at trial. The court rejected a showing-of-ineffectiveness requirement, relying on People v. Marsden, 2 Cal.3d 118, 84 Cal.Rptr. 156, 465 P.2d 44 (Cal.1970) and Farrell v. United States, 391 A.2d 755, 761-62 (D.C.1978): the denial forced a choice between counsel he believed unprepared and self-representation, and only a contemporaneous hearing builds a reviewable record. Unlike courts that order an automatic new trial (n.4), it remanded for a hearing. If the complaints justified substitution, a new trial follows; if not, the court re-enters the conviction. The holding is limited to a timely pretrial motion (n.1).

Issue 6: Sufficiency of the evidence (sufficiency of the evidence): affirmed (no error)

The defendant did not carry his burden. Under State v. Lemons, 844 P.2d 378, 381 (Utah Ct.App.1992), he had to marshal the evidence supporting the verdict. He relied instead on the victim’s post-trial recanting affidavits, which were not trial evidence.

Issue 7: The State’s motion to strike the recantation affidavits granted

The affidavits were offered only with two untimely new-trial motions, and “[A]ppellate courts of this state do not consider new evidence on appeal,” Finlayson v. Finlayson, 874 P.2d 843, 847 (Utah Ct.App.1994).

Not reached

  • Issue 2, ineffective assistance: the defendant had new counsel on appeal by appearing pro se, but the trial record was inadequate. A rule 23B remand was unavailable because he alleged no specific facts outside the record and did not identify the uncalled witnesses (n.5). The court reached this and the remaining claims only in case the trial court finds the substitution motion groundless.
  • Issue 3, due process (nondisclosure of exculpatory evidence; exclusionary-rule violations): not preserved, and plain error not shown, citing State v. Webb, 790 P.2d 65, 77 (Utah Ct.App.1990).
  • Issue 4, biased juror: no for-cause challenge, so precluded under Utah R. Crim. P. 12(d) and State v. DeMille, 756 P.2d 81, 85 (Utah 1988).
  • Issue 5, new-trial motions: already resolved in State v. Vessey, 957 P.2d 1239, 1239 (Utah Ct.App.1998) (both motions untimely).

Takeaways

  • A timely pretrial substitution request requires a meaningful inquiry; a same-day summary denial is error.
  • The remedy the court adopted is a remand for an evidentiary hearing, with a new trial only if the complaints justified substitution.
  • The court distinguished mid-trial or eve-of-trial requests, where trial courts get broader deference (n.1).
  • Post-trial recantation affidavits cannot support a sufficiency challenge on appeal.
Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State of Utah v. Vessey
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
967 P.2d 960
Case no.
951820-CA
Filed
1995
Decided
October 22, 1998
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Vessey
Disposition
Reversed and Remanded
At stake
A jury conviction for rape of a child, a first degree felony.

The panel

Judith M. BillingsAuthor
Pamela T. GreenwoodConcurred
Gregory K. OrmeConcurred

Parties & counsel

Vessey — AppellantIndividual(s)Self-represented
State of Utah — AppelleeState of Utah

Practice Tip

When a client files a timely pretrial request for new appointed counsel and the court denies it without inquiry, the remedy the court adopted is a remand for an evidentiary hearing on the complaints, so build a record of the specific grounds (Part I and n.1).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.