Utah Supreme Court · Published Opinion

Can the press see a prosecutor’s request to keep a probe secret? Kearns -Tribune Corp. v. Wilkinson

946 P.2d 372No. 960113Decided Sep 23, 1997Administrative & GovernmentPetition Granted

Holding

Because records under the Investigative Subpoena Powers Act are presumed open, members of the public including the press have standing to challenge secrecy orders, and section 77-22-2(8) does not authorize a court to keep the district attorney’s investigative secrecy application secret.

Key takeaways

The Utah Supreme Court sided with Kearns-Tribune and ordered the district court to give it the prosecutor’s secrecy application and the court’s secrecy order.

  • Under the Investigative Subpoena Powers Act, court records are presumed open, so members of the public, including the press, have standing to challenge secrecy orders.
  • The statute does not allow a court to keep the district attorney’s application for investigative secrecy itself secret.
  • The court did not decide whether the investigation or the underlying secrecy order was proper.

What happened?

Utah’s Investigative Subpoena Powers Act lets the attorney general, county attorneys and district attorneys investigate crimes using court-issued subpoenas (orders requiring people to testify or produce evidence). A prosecutor may also ask the court to keep the investigation secret.

In April 1997, Kearns-Tribune Corporation wrote to the district court asking for documents it believed the district attorney had filed, including the application to keep the file secret and the court’s secrecy order. The district attorney objected. The court had Kearns-Tribune intervene, meaning formally join the matter, and file a written motion. After argument, the judge ruled that Kearns-Tribune lacked standing (the right to bring the request at all) and, alternatively, had not shown good cause to open the application.

Kearns-Tribune then filed a petition for an extraordinary writ, a request asking the Utah Supreme Court to order a lower court to act.

What did each side argue?

Kearns-Tribune argued it had a right to see public court records so it could decide whether to challenge the secrecy order. The district attorney argued that the public has no right to see criminal investigation records, so Kearns-Tribune could not be harmed by being denied access.

Did Kearns-Tribune have standing?

Yes. The court applied its usual test: the party must be harmed by a government action, the action must cause the harm, and the relief must fix it. The harder question was harm.

The court agreed that the public ordinarily has no right to a prosecutor’s investigation records. But this statute lets records be kept secret only if the district attorney makes a required showing, which means the records are presumed open. That presumption gives the public, including the press, standing to challenge secrecy orders. The district attorney’s argument wrongly focused on whether Kearns-Tribune would eventually win.

Could the secrecy application itself be kept secret?

No. Everyone below had read the statute as allowing the secrecy application to be sealed. The court read the statute’s words and held that the provision they relied on covers only the papers asking to start the investigation, not the secrecy application. So the secrecy application is a public document. The Deseret News, as amicus curiae (a non-party that filed a brief), had made the same point.

The court added that even if such sealing were allowed, Kearns-Tribune would not have to show good cause. The burden is on the district attorney. If the secrecy order is challenged, the district attorney must make the showing again in open court.

What happens now?

The court vacated (set aside) the district court’s order and directed that court to give Kearns-Tribune the investigative secrecy application and the secrecy order. The court stressed it was not deciding whether the investigation or the secrecy order itself was proper.

What should people take from this?

Under this statute, a request to keep an investigation secret is a public filing. The court also noted that prosecutors may have real reasons for secrecy, such as concerns about witness intimidation, and that trial courts can hold closed (in camera) proceedings where warranted, though no one asked for that here.

Bottom line

Petition for extraordinary writ granted; the district court’s order is vacated (Zimmerman, C.J., joined by Howe, Durham and Russon, JJ.; Stewart, A.C.J., did not participate). The district court must give Kearns-Tribune the district attorney’s investigative secrecy application filed under Utah Code section 77-22-2(7)(a) and the investigative secrecy order. The opinion has no numbered paragraphs.

Issue 1: Standing and access to the secrecy application (mixed): Kearns-Tribune’s petition for an extraordinary writ granted

Kearns-Tribune had standing, and the statute does not permit the investigative secrecy application to be sealed, so the district court erred on both of its grounds.

Standing. The court reviews standing as primarily a question of law, deferring on factual findings but granting “minimal discretion” on whether the facts meet the legal test. Applying Society of Prof. Journalists v. Bullock, 743 P.2d 1166, 1174 (Utah 1987), causation and redressability were clear; injury was the hard prong. Although the public ordinarily has no right of access to prosecutors’ investigation records, section 77-22-2(7)(a) allows secrecy only on the district attorney’s showing, which implies the records are presumed open. That presumption gives the general public, including the press, standing to challenge secrecy orders. The district attorney’s argument wrongly conflated standing with ultimate success.

Statutory reading. Section 77-22-2(8) lets the district attorney seek secrecy for the “application and good cause showing for the order authorizing the investigation,” read as a whole phrase referring to the initiating papers under section 77-22-2(1)(a), not the investigative secrecy application under subsection (7)(a). The court found support in In re Criminal Investigation, 754 P.2d 633, 656 (Utah 1988), which read the omission of initiating papers from the former statute as meaning they could not be kept secret; the amendment cured that omission and no more. The amicus Deseret News made the same point (n.2). The secrecy application is therefore a public document.

Burden. Even assuming sealing were allowed, the district court misallocated the burden: the challenger need not show good cause for openness. The district attorney bears the burden, and once a secrecy order is challenged must make the showing again in open court, because the initial showing is always ex parte.

Kearns-Tribune dropped its request for the good cause statement and sought only the secrecy application and order (n.1).

Disposition

The order is vacated and the district court is ordered to grant access. The court expressly did not decide whether the order approving the investigation or the underlying investigative secrecy order was proper.

Takeaways

  • Under the Investigative Subpoena Powers Act, presumed openness of records supports public standing to challenge secrecy orders; a party need not first prove a right to the particular documents.
  • Section 77-22-2(8) reaches the initiating application and good cause showing, not the investigative secrecy application.
  • When a secrecy order is challenged, the district attorney must renew the showing in open court; the challenger does not bear a good-cause burden.
  • In a footnote, the court noted trial courts’ inherent power to proceed in camera where a secrecy application itself contains sensitive information, though no such request was made here (n.3).

Utah cases relied on

  • Society of Prof. Journalists v. Bullock743 P.2d 1166, 1174 (Utah 1987)
  • In re Criminal Investigation754 P.2d 633, 656 (Utah 1988)
Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Kearns -Tribune Corp. v. Wilkinson
Court
Utah Supreme Court
Citation
946 P.2d 372
Case no.
960113
Filed
1996
Decided
September 23, 1997
Opinion type
Authored
Heard
Argued
Disposition
Petition Granted
At stake
A newspaper's access to the district attorney's investigative secrecy application and the district court's secrecy order in an Investigative Subpoena Powers Act investigation.

The panel

Michael D. ZimmermanAuthor
I. Daniel StewartDid not participate
Christine M. DurhamConcurred
Richard C. HoweConcurred
Leonard H. RussonConcurred
Trial court
Third Judicial District Court, State of Utah, Salt Lake County · Judge Homer F. Wilkinson

Parties & counsel

Appellant — AppellantBusinessMichael Patrick O'BrienSharon E. Sonnenreich
Appellee — AppelleeGovernment agencyBrent M. Johnson

Practice Tip

When seeking access to Investigative Subpoena Powers Act filings, rely on the statute's presumption of openness for standing, and note that once a secrecy order is challenged the district attorney must again make the required showing in open court (the opinion has no numbered paragraphs).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.