Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can pleading guilty to a traffic ticket block a homicide charge? State of Utah v. Turner

980 P.2d 1188No. 971744-CADecided Dec 10, 1998Criminal AppealsReversed & Remanded

Holding

A trial court has discretion under Utah R. Crim. P. 11(e) to refuse a guilty plea, and accepting a plea to driving left of center over the State’s timely and specific objections, which barred prosecution of a negligent homicide charge based on the same act under Utah Code Ann. § 76-1-402(1), was an abuse of discretion requiring the plea and sentence to be set aside and the dismissal vacated.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the State and sent the negligent homicide case back to the trial court.

  • A defendant has no absolute right to have a guilty plea accepted; the court may refuse it.
  • Here, accepting a plea to the lesser traffic charge over the State’s timely and specific objections was unfair and unreasonable, because it effectively cut off the homicide prosecution.
  • The plea, the sentence and the dismissal of the negligent homicide charge were all undone, and the case goes back to the trial court.

What happened?

Turner, the defendant, was driving in Millard County and towing a trailer when he entered a sweeping curve and crossed the center line into the oncoming lane. A motorcyclist coming the other way collided with him and died.

The State filed one charging document with two counts: negligent homicide, and driving left of center. At his first court appearance, Turner pleaded guilty to driving left of center and not guilty to negligent homicide. He then asked to be sentenced right away on the traffic charge.

Why did the State object?

The State argued that Turner was trying to create a “double jeopardy” problem, meaning a bar on being tried twice for the same conduct. A Utah statute says that when one act breaks two laws, a conviction and sentence under one law bars prosecution under the other. The State asked the court not to accept the plea.

The first judge had doubts and said so, but defense counsel persuaded the court that it had to accept the plea. A second judge sentenced Turner over the State’s objection. A third judge then dismissed the negligent homicide charge, again over the State’s objection.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It sided with the State. A defendant has no absolute right to have a guilty plea accepted. Utah’s criminal rules say the court “may refuse to accept a plea of guilty.”

The trial court had a choice, so the question was whether it abused its discretion, meaning whether its decision was unfair or went beyond the limits of what is reasonable. The Court of Appeals held that it did. Accepting the plea over the State’s timely and specific objections effectively wiped out the State’s right to prosecute the homicide charge. The court pointed out that society and the State have an interest in a fair resolution of criminal cases.

What about the sentence and the dismissal?

The court said that once the plea was accepted, the trial court properly sentenced Turner within the time the rules required. It also said that once he was convicted and sentenced, the statute did bar the homicide prosecution, so the dismissal followed. But both steps rested on the plea that should not have been accepted. So the sentence was set aside and the dismissal order was vacated, meaning cancelled.

What about double jeopardy under the U.S. Constitution?

The court said that question was “not squarely before us.” It noted that a U.S. Supreme Court decision on similar facts was consistent with its ruling.

What happens now?

The case goes back to the trial court for further proceedings. The guilty plea, the sentence and the dismissal of the negligent homicide charge are no longer in place.

What should people take from this?

When the State has charged a serious offense and a lesser offense based on the same act, a court has discretion to refuse a guilty plea to the lesser charge. In this case, accepting that plea over the State’s objections was an abuse of that discretion.

Bottom line

Plea and sentence set aside, dismissal order vacated, and remanded for further proceedings (Davis, P.J., joined by Jackson and Orme, JJ.). A trial court may refuse a guilty plea under Utah R. Crim. P. 11(e), and accepting a plea to a lesser traffic offense over the State’s timely and specific objections, where doing so barred prosecution of negligent homicide arising from the same act, was an abuse of discretion. The opinion has no numbered paragraphs.

Issue 1: Acceptance of the guilty plea over the State’s objection (abuse of discretion): reversed and remanded

The trial court abused its discretion by accepting the defendant’s plea to driving left of center over the State’s objection, so the plea, the sentence and the order dismissing the negligent homicide count all fall.

Discretion to refuse. A defendant has no absolute right to have a guilty plea accepted, citing Lynch v. Overholser, 369 U.S. 705, 719, 82 S.Ct. 1063, 1072, 8 L.Ed.2d 211 (1962), and Rule 11(e) provides that “[t]he court may refuse to accept a plea of guilty.” Under State v. Mane, 783 P.2d 61, 66 (Utah Ct.App.1989), nothing in the rule requires a court to accept a plea. The record suggested the court accepted the plea on the mistaken view that it was obliged to, so the court reviewed whether acceptance was an abuse of discretion.

Abuse of discretion. Acceptance over the State’s timely and specific objections was “unfair and unreasonable,” effectively nullifying the State’s right to prosecute negligent homicide. The court relied on the State’s interest in “an error free determination of the case,” quoting State v. Lamorie, 610 P.2d 342, 348 (Utah 1980) (Stewart, J., concurring).

Sentence. Once the plea was accepted and the defendant insisted on sentencing, Utah R. Crim. P. 22(a) required sentencing within 45 days, and the court correctly imposed sentence. Because the sentence rested on the erroneous acceptance of the plea, it is set aside.

Dismissal. Under Utah Code Ann. § 76-1-402(1), the conviction and sentence for driving left of center, the same act underlying the homicide count, barred prosecution on that count, so the dismissal was correct on its own terms. Because it rested on the mistaken acceptance of the plea, the order is vacated.

Federal double jeopardy. The Fifth Amendment claim was “not squarely before us,” but the court noted that Ohio v. Johnson, 467 U.S. 493, 501-02, 104 S.Ct. 2536, 2542, 81 L.Ed.2d 425 (1984), is consistent with its ruling (n.1).

Disposition

The acceptance of the plea and the sentence are set aside, the dismissal is vacated, and the case is remanded for further proceedings consistent with the opinion.

Takeaways

  • A trial court is not obliged to accept a guilty plea; Rule 11(e) leaves the decision to the court’s discretion.
  • When a plea to a lesser charge would trigger the § 76-1-402(1) bar on a greater charge from the same act, accepting it over the State’s timely and specific objections was held an abuse of discretion here.
  • Downstream rulings that are correct on their own terms (Rule 22(a) sentencing, a § 76-1-402(1) dismissal) still fall when they rest on an erroneously accepted plea.
  • Make the objection timely and specific at each stage, as the State did at the plea, sentencing and dismissal hearings.
Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
State of Utah v. Turner
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
980 P.2d 1188
Case no.
971744-CA
Filed
1997
Decided
December 10, 1998
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
State of Utah
Disposition
Reversed and Remanded
At stake
Whether the State could still prosecute a negligent homicide charge after the defendant pleaded guilty to, and was sentenced for, driving left of center in the same criminal episode.

The panel

James Z. DavisAuthor
Norman H. JacksonConcurred
Gregory K. OrmeConcurred
Trial court
Fourth Judicial District Court

Parties & counsel

State of Utah — AppellantState of Utah
Turner — AppelleeIndividual(s)

Practice Tip

When a defendant offers a plea to a lesser charge that would trigger the § 76-1-402(1) bar on a greater charge from the same act, prosecutors should object timely and specifically and remind the court that Rule 11(e) lets it refuse the plea, as the State did in State of Utah v. Turner.

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.