Utah Court of Appeals · Per Curiam Opinion

Can I undo a settlement release by calling it unfair? Red Bridge Capital v. JAR Family Investment Co.

2014 UT App 21No. 20130365-CADecided Jan 24, 2014Contracts & Business DisputesAffirmed

Holding

A district court’s statement that both procedural and substantive unconscionability are required did not require reversal where it found neither, and borrowers who offered no analysis of the substantive-unconscionability factors failed to carry their burden of showing a settlement release unenforceable.

Key takeaways

The Utah Court of Appeals sided with the lender, Red Bridge Capital, and upheld its summary judgment win on both its claim and the borrowers’ counterclaim.

  • A release in a settlement agreement that clearly covers a claim can support summary judgment on that claim.
  • Under Utah law, unfairness in a contract’s terms alone may make it unconscionable, but the court did not reverse here because the district court found neither kind of unfairness.
  • A party challenging a contract term as unfair on appeal must explain, with analysis of the relevant factors, why the term is unfair.

What happened?

Beginning in 2005, Red Bridge Capital, LLC (the lender) made construction loans of $1.9 million to JAR Family Investment Co., Ltd. (the borrower). Jay R. Rice and Anita A. Rice guaranteed the loans, meaning they promised to pay if the borrower did not.

After a default, Red Bridge sued and got a default judgment. The parties then settled. The borrower signed a $400,000 promissory note, the Rices guaranteed it, and both sides exchanged releases giving up claims against each other.

Why did the case come back to court?

The borrower and the Rices (together, the defendants) defaulted on the settlement too. Red Bridge sued again. The defendants filed a counterclaim, a claim of their own against Red Bridge, saying Red Bridge made misrepresentations during the loan negotiations, caused their inability to repay, and failed to release a lien on a property.

The district court granted summary judgment, a ruling without a trial because the key facts were not disputed, for Red Bridge on its claim and on the counterclaim.

What did the defendants argue?

They argued the release was unconscionable, meaning so unfair a court should refuse to enforce it. They said the district court wrongly required two kinds of unfairness: unfairness in how the deal was made (procedural) and unfairness in its terms (substantive). They also argued the release’s terms were substantively unfair.

What did the court decide?

The Court of Appeals affirmed. It noted that the counterclaim was based on claims that arose before the release, so the release covered them.

On the first point, the court explained that under Commercial Real Estate Investment, L.C. v. Comcast of Utah II, Inc., 2012 UT 49, ¶ 42, 285 P.3d 1193, unfair terms alone may be enough. But the district court had ruled the release was neither procedurally nor substantively unconscionable. So its statement that both were needed did not require reversal.

On the second point, the court held the defendants had not adequately briefed their argument. They did no analysis of the factors courts use to judge whether terms are so one-sided that they oppress an innocent party. Because of that, they did not carry their burden of persuading the court.

What happens now?

Nothing goes back to the district court. The summary judgment for Red Bridge on its complaint and on the defendants’ counterclaim stands.

What should people take from this?

A broad release in a settlement can end later claims about events that came before it. A party who wants a court to refuse to enforce a term as unfair needs to explain why, using the factors courts apply, and not just say the term is unfair.

Bottom line

Affirmed (per curiam; Davis, McHugh and Voros, JJ.). JAR Family Investment and guarantors Jay and Anita Rice settled a default judgment with Red Bridge Capital, signing a $400,000 note and exchanging mutual releases (¶ 2). After a second default, the district court granted summary judgment for Red Bridge on its complaint and on the defendants’ counterclaims, which arose before the release (¶¶ 2, 4, 9). Where a release unambiguously bars a claim, summary judgment is proper (¶ 4, citing Palmer v. Davis, 808 P.2d 128, 132 (Utah Ct. App. 1991)).

Issue 1: Two-prong unconscionability statement (none stated, ¶¶ 5–6): affirmed (harmless error)

The district court’s statement that both procedural and substantive unconscionability are required did not require reversal. Under Commercial Real Estate Investment, L.C. v. Comcast of Utah II, Inc., 2012 UT 49, ¶ 42, 285 P.3d 1193, “substantive unconscionability alone may support a finding of unconscionability” (¶ 5). The analysis looks at the relative fairness of the obligations at the time of contracting, and an improvident bargain is not enough (¶ 5, citing Park Valley Corp. v. Bagley, 635 P.2d 65, 68 (Utah 1981)). Because the district court ruled the release was neither procedurally nor substantively unconscionable on the undisputed facts, its misstatement did not matter (¶ 6).

Issue 2: Substantive unconscionability of the release (none stated, ¶¶ 7–8): affirmed (no error)

The defendants failed to carry their burden of persuasion that the release was substantively unconscionable. They undertook “no analysis” of the relevant factors (¶ 7). The court set out the test from Ryan v. Dan’s Food Stores, Inc., 972 P.2d 395, 402 (Utah 1998): terms must be so one-sided as to oppress or unfairly surprise an innocent party, and a term that is merely unreasonable or more advantageous to one party is not enough (¶ 7). Relying on Mercado v. Hill, 2012 UT App 44, ¶ 11, 273 P.3d 385, and State v. Green, 2004 UT 76, ¶ 13, 99 P.3d 820, the court held that rule 24(a)(9) of the Utah Rules of Appellate Procedure requires development of authority and reasoned analysis, which the defendants did not supply (¶ 8).

Takeaways

  • A clear and unambiguous release covering pre-settlement claims supports summary judgment on counterclaims based on those claims (¶ 4).
  • A trial court’s misstatement that both unconscionability prongs are required is not reversible where it found neither prong met (¶¶ 5–6).
  • An unconscionability argument on appeal must analyze the substantive-unconscionability factors from Ryan v. Dan’s Food Stores, Inc., 972 P.2d 395, 402 (Utah 1998); a bare assertion fails to carry the burden of persuasion (¶¶ 7–8).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Red Bridge Capital v. JAR Family Investment Co.
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2014 UT App 21
Case no.
20130365-CA
Filed
2013
Decided
January 24, 2014
Opinion type
Per curiam
Who appealed
JAR Family Investment Co.
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Summary judgment for a lender on a borrower's and guarantors' default under a $400,000 settlement note, and on their counterclaims barred by a release in the settlement agreement

The panel

James Z. DavisPer curiam
J. Frederic Voros, Jr.Per curiam
Carolyn B. McHughPer curiam
Trial court
Third District Court, Salt Lake Department · Judge Anthony B. Quinn

Parties & counsel

JAR Family Investment Co. — AppellantOtherThomas J. KlcPeter A. Klc
Red Bridge Capital — AppelleeBusinessTimothy J. DanceBrock N. Worthen

Practice Tip

When challenging a release as substantively unconscionable on appeal, analyze the one-sidedness and oppression factors from Ryan v. Dan's Food Stores, Inc., 972 P.2d 395, 402 (Utah 1998), and apply them to the facts; bare assertions fail to carry the burden of persuasion (¶¶ 7–8).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.