Utah Court of Appeals · Published Opinion

Can a mediated settlement be undone for hiding a land purchase? Baadsgaard Family Trust v. Stevens

2026 UT App 68No. 20240921-CADecided Apr 30, 2026Real Property & Land UseAffirmed

Holding

The district court did not abuse its rule 60(b) discretion in vacating enforcement of a mediated settlement where the Trust breached a contractual duty to disclose all relevant information by withholding its recent purchase of a parcel bearing on the “adjoining landowners” element of its boundary-by-acquiescence claim, and constructive notice from the recorded deed did not excuse that duty.

Key takeaways

The Court of Appeals sided with the Stevenses, the neighbors the Trust had sued, and left in place the order undoing the mediated settlement.

  • When parties sign a mediation agreement promising to disclose all relevant information, that promise can go beyond what public property records already show.
  • A court may set aside an order enforcing a mediated settlement when a party breaks that promise, and the appeals court gives the trial court wide room on that decision.
  • Here the Court of Appeals did not read the trial court’s ruling as resting on confidential mediation talks.

What happened?

The Baadsgaard Family Trust (the Trust) and Robert and Suzanne Stevens own neighboring land. A long-standing fence was treated as the boundary, but it turned out the Trust’s cattle and hay operation was using part of the Stevenses’ property.

The Trust sued to “quiet title,” meaning to have the court declare it the owner of that strip, under a theory called boundary by acquiescence. That theory requires, among other things, that the two owners were “adjoining landowners” whose land touched for at least 20 years.

The parties went to mediation, a negotiation led by a neutral person. Their mediation agreement included a promise “to be honest and to completely disclose all relevant information.” It said a settlement could be voided if a party did not. They settled, with the Stevenses agreeing to deed part of the strip to the Trust, and the district court later enforced the settlement.

What went wrong?

Shortly before suing, the Trust had bought a small parcel, the East Parcel, lying between part of its land and part of the Stevenses’ land. The Stevenses said they did not know the purchase was recent. They asked the court to set aside the enforcement order under rule 60(b), a rule that lets a court undo its own orders for reasons such as fraud or misconduct.

The district court agreed. It found the information was material and the Trust had a duty to disclose it. It later dismissed the Trust’s claims and ordered the fence removed.

What did the Trust argue?

The Trust argued the East Parcel did not matter to its claim, that the Stevenses could have found the recorded deed, that the court read the honesty promise too broadly, and that the court relied on confidential mediation discussions.

What did the Court of Appeals decide?

It affirmed. Trial courts have broad discretion, meaning wide room to decide, on these motions.

Who owned the East Parcel affected whether the Trust was an “adjoining landowner” whose cattle could have used the strip for 20 years. So the purchase was relevant and “absolutely should have been disclosed.”

The recorded deed did not help the Trust. By signing the honesty promise, the parties agreed to more than what public records show. The court also said the promise’s words were clear and the Trust’s complaint about reading minds was “rather hyperbolic.”

On confidentiality, the district court said it relied mainly on the Stevenses’ own written answer in the court file, not on what was said in mediation. The appeals court did not read the ruling as depending on confidential talks.

What happens now?

The order undoing the enforcement of the settlement stands. The Court of Appeals did not send the case back.

What should people take from this?

A written promise in a mediation agreement to disclose all relevant information is binding. A party who holds back relevant facts risks losing the settlement it reached.

Bottom line

Affirmed (Orme, J., joined by Christiansen Forster and Tenney, JJ.). The district court did not abuse its broad discretion in granting the Stevenses’ rule 60(b) motion and vacating its order enforcing a mediated settlement, because the Trust did not disclose its recent acquisition of the East Parcel as the mediation agreement’s Honesty Provision required (¶¶ 26–27). The district court did not say whether it relied on rule 60(b)(3) or 60(b)(6), and the Trust did not draw the distinction; the court held relief was within discretion under either (¶ 19). It noted that 60(b)(6) applies only if no other subsection does, but took the question as briefed (¶ 19 n.3).

Issue 1: Duty to disclose under the Honesty Provision (abuse of discretion, ¶ 16): affirmed (no error)

The Trust’s purchase of the East Parcel was relevant and should have been disclosed under the Honesty Provision. Boundary by acquiescence requires “adjoining landowners” for 20 years, and landowners are adjoining when their properties are “contiguous,” Bahr v. Imus, 2011 UT 19, ¶ 38, 250 P.3d 56; see Staker v. Ainsworth, 785 P.2d 417, 420 (Utah 1990) (¶ 20). Ownership of the East Parcel, which sat between the properties at the disputed parcel’s eastern boundary, bore on whether the Trust was an adjoining landowner whose cattle occupied the parcel, measured against Utah R. Evid. 401 (¶ 21).

Constructive notice from the recorded deed, see Lavender v. FCOI Preserve, LLC, 2025 UT App 47, ¶ 72, 569 P.3d 1037, cert. denied, 570 P.3d 660 (Utah 2025), did not help: the parties “contracted over and above” recording-statute notice, and the agreed duty of full disclosure controls (¶ 22). The provision’s plain language made the parties’ intent clear, and the district court read it in light of their reasonable expectations, citing Bennion v. Stolrow, 2024 UT 14, ¶ 17, 550 P.3d 474; the Trust’s “impossible task” objection was “rather hyperbolic” (¶¶ 23–24).

Issue 2: Reliance on confidential mediation communications (abuse of discretion, ¶ 16): affirmed (no error)

The court did not read the district court’s ruling as relying on confidential mediation communications. Mediation confidentiality “is to be carefully observed,” Reese v. Tingey Constr., 2008 UT 7, ¶ 14, 177 P.3d 605, but the district court said it relied less on the Stevenses’ account of mediation than on their pro se answer on file (¶ 25). The finding about who persuaded whom went to the effect of the nondisclosure, not to whether a duty to disclose existed (¶ 25).

Takeaways

  • A contractual mediation disclosure duty can reach beyond the constructive notice the recording statutes provide (¶ 22).
  • Relevance under such a provision can be measured against the elements of the claim, here the “adjoining landowners” and occupation elements of boundary by acquiescence (¶¶ 20–21).
  • A pleading on file showing the opponent’s defense theory can support a finding that the withheld fact was relevant without resort to mediation communications (¶ 25).
  • Showing an abuse of discretion on a rule 60(b) ruling “requires more than simply disagreeing” with the district court (¶ 26).

Utah cases relied on

Read the full opinion (PDF)

Case details

Case name
Baadsgaard Family Trust v. Stevens
Court
Utah Court of Appeals
Citation
2026 UT App 68
Case no.
20240921-CA
Filed
2024
Decided
April 30, 2026
Opinion type
Authored
Who appealed
Baadsgaard Family Trust
Disposition
Affirmed
At stake
Whether a mediated settlement requiring the Stevenses to deed part of a disputed parcel to the Trust would be enforced, in the Trust's boundary-by-acquiescence quiet title suit

The panel

Gregory K. OrmeAuthor
Michele M. Christiansen ForsterConcurred
Ryan D. TenneyConcurred
Trial court
Fourth District Court, Provo Department · Judge Thomas Low

Parties & counsel

Baadsgaard Family Trust — AppellantOtherJens P. Nielson
Stevens — AppelleeIndividual(s)Joseph G. Ballstaedt

Practice Tip

If a mediation agreement includes a full-disclosure clause, do not rely on recorded documents as notice; disclose facts bearing on the elements of the claims and defenses, since the court held the contractual duty goes beyond recording-statute notice (¶ 22).

Need appellate counsel?

Lotus Appellate Law handles appeals before the Utah Court of Appeals, Utah Supreme Court, California Court of Appeal, and the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit.

About these Decision Summaries

Lotus Appellate Law publishes these summaries to keep practitioners informed — not as legal advice. Each case turns on its own facts. If a decision here is relevant to your matter, we’re happy to discuss it.